Information processing apparatus



July 9, 1963 F. l.. PUTZRATH ETAL 3,097,349

INFORMATION PROCESSING APPARATUS Filed Aug. 28, 1961 9 Sheets-Sheet 1 4 r raf/vi r 0077907' PULSE AE July 9, 1963 F. PuTzRATH ETAI. 3,097349 INFORMATION PROCESSING APPARATUS F'iled Aug. 28, 1961 9 Sheets-Sheet 2 Irfan/fr July 9, 1963 F` PUTzRATH ETAL 3,097,349

INFORMATION PROCESSING APPARATUS 9 Sheets-Sheet 5 Filed Aug. 28. 1961 July 9, 1963 F. 1 PuTzRATH ETAL 3,097,349

INFORMATION PROCESSING APPARATUS Filed Aug. 28. 1951 9 Sheets-Sheet 4 l@ l2. l@ f aar/ar F///VG AArf-(a/bj JX/4y- A/ z Fg' D I4. j a .//4 fla 57 July 9, 1963 F. L. PuTzRATH ETAI. 3,097,349

INFORMATION PROCESSING APPARATUS F'iled Aug. 28, 1961 9 Sheets-Sheet 5 Fg' .16. 156 Q L IUUULIUUUL ox 58 d- Non! 0 mi? zf/rze [44 f 5 X46 J'//42-7 am# A/ Mx l 154 July 9, 1963 F. PUTzRATH ETAL 3,097,349

INFORMATION PROCESSING APPARATUS Filed Aug. 28. 1961 9 Sheets-Sheet 6 fda t7 200 ZZC 200 204.7 d Z 7 20.67%@ [fig d 200 202 ZOZ- I wif/i1 Mfg/7 I7 n o B Y 1 i 172 Arran/EY July 9, 1963 F. L. PuTzRATH ETAL 3,097,349

INFORMATION PROCESSING APPARATUS F'iled Aug. 28, 1961 9 Sheets-Sheet 7 I au e215 +451 July 9, 1963 F. PUTZRATH ETAL 3,097,349

INFORMATION PROCESSING APPARATUS Filed Aug. 28. 1961 9 Sheets-Sheet 8 X Q 80 E 60 d v '5, 4o 2 z/ H 20 /oo 00a /q 000 rfi@ (am n K) m0 moo /gaaa frm. @aan oo ma a Fifa.

4 4p 4 4M? LT Y T -1- X if:

442 442 242 434 44B 444%432 442 452 45a 446 4 i A/ 4 ,V444 A/ 440 Flj yf r4 Hr f July 9, 1963 F. 1 PUTzRATH ETAL 3,097,349

INFORMATION PROCESSING APPARATUS Filed Aug. 28, 1961 9 Sheets-Sheet 9 D muuu Humm 5 @Qu/*Ty E y c|||| Hm um INV EN TORI iA/z @fri/My r MPA/EY United States Patent O 3,9913@ INFORMATIN PROCESSING APPARATUS Franz L. Putzrath, Oaklyn, and Thomas B. Martin, Collingswood, NJ., assignors to Radio Corporation of America. :l corporation of Delaware Filed Aug. Z8, 1961, Ser. No. 134,368 9 Claims. ((L 340-1725) The present invention relates to information processsing apparatus, and more particularly to electrical apparatus for recognizing patterns, such as speech patterns, by simulated neural processes.

The invention is especially suitable for providing electrical networks and systems for analyzing patterns, such as the sound patterns which exist in speech, and for logically processing information obtained from such patterns so as to recognize certain speech sounds. The invention is also generally useful for translating information into electrical signals suitable for logical processing, and for logically processing the information represented by such signals.

As of the present time, there are no known electrical systems which are capable of abstracting information and processing such information with the same facility as the biological nervous system. By the biological nervous system is meant the receptor organs, such as the ear and other sense organs, the brain, and the nerve networks interconnecting the receptor organs and the brain. Biological nervous systems have been studied. These studies are discussed in the Handbook of Experimental Psychology, Chapter 2, pages 50-93 (John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1950). The basic building blocks of the biological nervous system are neurons which generate electrical impulses by a complex cycle of electrochemical changes. The neurons have two states, active or inactive. The neurons fire, or become active, in response to excitation of greater than a threshold intensity. Neurons also respond to intensity. The number of firings in a given time interval increases as the intensity rises. The number of tirings, however, saturates to a maximum number which biological research has found to be around 3G() pulses per second. The saturation effect occurs because the electrochemical processes in the nerves, which are believed responsible for the generation of each impulse, require a recuperative period between tirings. This recuperative period is called the refractory period.

Attempts have been made to artificially mechanize biological neurons. Circuits have been provided which provide pulses in response to excitation of intensity greater than a given threshold intensity, which have refractory periods between output pulses and which have other properties of biological neurons. Known artificial neurons, for the most part, have not been adapted to perform logical functions, such as `determining whether or not different events have taken place, whether one event preceded another, whether the events occurred simultaneously or sequentially, and the like. The input and output characteristics of artificial neurons have made them unsuitable for information processing where a large amount of information is involved. Biological nervous systems are known to be capable of processing a very large amount of information almost simultaneously. Most known artificial neurons are impractical for handling complex information in large quantities without introducing noise and other signal distortions.

Nerve networks of biological nervous systems are believed to logically process information by numerous logical operations having both digital and analog characteristics. It is desirable to perform similar logical operations using circuit neurons. A complex variety of logical functions are also preformed by an entire biological nervous system in the abstracting processing of information. It is also 3,097,349 Patented July 9, 1963 desirable to artificially perform logical functions of similar complexity with systems of circuit neurons and circuit neuron networks.

It is an object of the present invention to provide improved apparatus for processing speech information which operates similarly in principle to the human cochlea and its associated nervous system.

It is a still further object of the present invention to provide apparatus for artificially mechanizing the human cochlea so as to simulate the psychoacoustic phenomena attributable thereto better than those known heretofore.

It is a still further object of the present invention to provide an improved neural system suitable for speech recognition.

It is a still further object of the present invention to provide an artificial cochlea improved over prior articial cochleas.

It has been proposed to provide an artificial cochlea which involves a combination of a multi-section low-pass filter type of transmission line and a plurality of circuit neurons connected, successively, to different points along this line. The present invention involves a system of circuit neurons which are connected to the transmission line. A plurality of circuit neurons are provided in this system, each of which` corresponds to a different section of the transmission line.

The neurons responsive to signals transmitted by succeeding sections of the line are connected in inhibitory feedback relationship with the neurons which are responsive to the signals which are transmitted by preceding sections of the line. Thus, neurons responsive to lower frequency signals may partially inhibit neurons responsive to higher frequency signals. ln this manner, various psychoacoustic phenomena attributable to the human cochlea may be simulated. For example, it is known that lower frequency sounds mask high frequency sounds so that a listener cannot perceive high frequency sounds in the presence of intense low frequency sounds. Since neurons corresponding to sections of the line which pass higher frequency signals are inhibited by neurons which correspond to sections of the line which pass higher frequency signals, this masking phenomenon is simulated.

The circuit neurons which are useful in the system embodying the present invention involve a plurality of circuits including an input circuit for combining a plurality of excitatory and `inhibitory inputs which occur over a given period of time. A threshold circuit maintains the neuron quiescently in the inactive state. When the excitatory inputs exceed the inhibitory inputs and a built in threshold, the neuron becomes active or fires. A pulse generator operated by the threshold circuit translates the amount by which the excitatory inputs exceed the inhibitory inputs `and the threshold into an output pulse rate. Corresponding output pulses so provided have excitatory and inhibitory characteristics. The system of circuits also includes a circuit which introduces refractory characteristics in the neuron whereby the output pulse rate varies non-linearly with increasing excitatory stimulation.

The artificial coehlea provided by the invention may also be used together with a system of neural networks for recognizing speech sounds. The invention will, therefore, be better understood from a discussion of the circuit neuron, neural networks, and neural systems involved therein.

The invention itself, both as to its organization and method of operation, as well as additional objects and advantages thereof, will become more readily apparent from a reading of the following `description in connection with the accompanying drawings in which:

FIG. l is a block `diagram of an electrical circuit neuron;

FIG. 2 is a block diagram used hereinafter to symbolize 3 an electrical circuit neuron of the type illustrated in FIG. l;

FIGS. 3 to 5 are curves showing different input-output characteristics obtainable with the electrical circuit neuron Vshown in FIG. 1;

FIG. 6 is a schematic diagram of a neuron of the type shown in FIG. l;

FIG. 7 is a partially schematic, partially block diagram of another neuron of the type shown inFIG. l;

FIG. 8 is a family of curves which illustrate the input characteristics of the neuron circuit shown in FIGS. 7 and 8;

FIG. 9 is a partially block, partially schematic diagram ,of still another neuron of the type shown in FIG. l;

FIG. 10 illustrates a waveform which occurs during operation of the circuit shown in FIG. 9;

FIG. 1l is a partially block, partially schematic diagram of a neural network which responds to differences between excitatory and inhibitory inputs;

FIG. 12 illustrates a family of curves illustrating the operation of the network shown in FIG. 1l;

FIG. 13 is a partially block, partially schematic diagram of a neural network which enhances mutual differences between different inputs;

FIG. 14 illustrates a curve representing the input-output characteristics of the network shown in FIG. 13;

FIG. 15 is a partially schematic, partially block diagram of a neural network which performs the logical AND function;

FIG. 16 is a block diagram of a symbol representing the neural network of FIG. 15;

FIG. 17 is a partially schematic, partially block diagr-am of a neural network which responds to the onset of an input;

FIG. 18 illustrates three waveforms from different points in the network of FIG. 17;

FIG. 19 is a block diagram of a symbol which represents the neural network of FIG. I7;

FIG. 20 is a partially block, partially schematic diagram of the neural network which responds to the cessation of an input;

FIG. 21 illustrates three waveforms from different points in the network of FIG. 20;

FIG. 22 is a diagram of a symbol representing the neural network of FIG. 20;

FIG. 23 is a partially schematic, partially block diagram of a neural network for determining changes in an input;

FIG. 24 illustrates three waveforms from different points of the network of FIG. 23;

FIG. 25 is a partially block, partially schematic diagram of a neural network which determines the priority of two inputs with respect to each other;

FIG. 26 is a diagram of a symbol representing the neural network of FIG. 25;

FIG. 27a and FIG. 27h, taken together is a partially schematic, partially block diagram of a portion of system of neural networks for logically processing information represented by a plurality of inputs, and also showing a pair of curves illustrating such inputs;

FIG. 28 is a fragmentary, partially schematic, partially block diagram showing a system which functions as an artificial cochlea and is useful for speech analysis;

FIG. 29 illustrates a family of curves of loudness level variations with frequency which are simulated by the system of FIG. 28;

FIG. 30 illustrates a curve representing the response characteristic of the system shown in FIG. 28 for sounds of about 2000 c.p.s.;

FIG. 31 illustrates a curve representing the psychological phenomena of masking which is simulated by the system shown in FIG. 2S;

FIG. 32 illustrates a series of waveforms obtainable with the system of FIG. 28;

fil)

4 FIG. 33 illustrates another series of waveforms obtainable with the system of FIG. 28; and

FIG. 34 is a fragmentary, partially block, partially schematic diagram of another system which artificially simulates a cochlea and is useful for speech analysis.

Electrical Circuit Neurons Referring more particularly to FIG. l, there is shown a system of circuits which provides an electrical circuit neuron 10. A plurality of inputs a to n, which may be inhibitory or excitatory, are applied to a signal combining and isolation circuit 12. These inputs may be pulse trains or analog signals. This circuit has a low input impedance and a high output impedance and effectively isolates the inputs from the remainder of the circuits of the neuron 10. The combined outputs are applied to an integration circuit 14 having a suthciently long time constant to accumulate inputs which occur over a finite time. The integration circuit provides temporal properties (response to input signals which occur over a finite period of time) in the neuron 10.

The output of the integration circuit 14l is applied to a threshold circuit 16 which tires when the integrated sum of the inputs exceeds a certain threshold level. This threshold level is denoted by the symbol 0. When the threshold circuit lires, it operates a pulse generating circuit 18 to generate a pulse. By "Iiring or fires" is meant that the state of the circuit is changed from its inactive quiescent state to its active state so as to provide an output signal. The pulse generating circuit 18 provides an excitatory pulse on its x output, and an inhibitory pulse on its y output. The pulse generating circuit 18 has a low output impedance which permits it to be coupled .to other circuit neurons Without additional impedance matching circuits. The excitatory and inhibitory pulses are bi-polar and complementary. Thus, the excitatory pulses may be positive voltage pulses and the inhibitory pulses may be negative voltage pulses. The excitatory and inhibitory pulses are of equal amplitude so as to facilitate equal strength excitation and inhibition of other neurons.

The pulse generating circuit and the threshold circuit are also interconnected by a refractory circuit 20 which prevents the threshold circuit from tiring the pulse generating circuit while a pulse is being generated and for a predetermined period thereafter. The refractory circuit also provides a non-linear analog response from the circuit neuron such that the output pulse rate, both excitatory and inhibitory, will depend upon the extent to which the input signal magnitude exceeds the threshold for neuron firing.

A symbol for the electrical circuit neuron which is used in the drawing is shown in FIG. 2. This symbol is a rectangular block inscribed with the latter N. A plurality of inputs a to n, inclusive, may be applied to the neuron. The excitatory output is labeled with the letter x and the inhibitory output is labeled with the letter y.

The normal input-output characteristic of the circuit neuron I0 is shown in FIG. 3. The abscissa of the curve is calibrated in terms of either the input pulse rate or signal amplitude for excitatory (positive) signals, as the case may be. The ordinate is calibrated in terms of the pulse rate of the pulse train obtainable either at the cxcitatory or at the inhibitory output. The neuron does not fire or generate an output pulse until the threshold 0 is reached. After the threshold is exceeded, the output pulse rate increases as a non-linear function of the input pulse rate or signal amplitude and depends upon how much the input pulse rate or signal amplitude exceeds the threshold. The output pulse rate saturatcs at a maximum pulse rate which is established by thc refractory circuit 20. The curve of FIG. 3 illustrates that the neuron 10 has analog and digital properties. The digital properties are that the neuron is either tiring or non-firing and depends upon the inputs exceeding or not exceeding the threshold. The analog property is the output pulse rate or the rate at which the neuron lires.

The input-output characteristic shown in FIG. 4 is obtninable by excitatory feedback; that is, as soon as the threshold is exceeded above a certain threshold 6, sufficient excitation is fed back to the input circuit to maintain the input to the circuit above 9. FIG. shows input-output characteristic obtainable by inhibitory feedback. Saturation in the output pulse rate requires a greater input pulse rate, for example, when inhibitory feedback is used.

The circuit neuron has (l) summation of inputs, (2) short term memory or temporal characteristics, (3) built-in threshold, (4) output pulses, and (5) refractoriness, which biological research has shown to be inherent in biological neurons. The circuit neuron of FIG. l0, however, also has characteristics which make it practical for use in complex neural networks and neural systems. These characteristics are (1) low input and output impedances, (2) integration circuits isouted from the input connections so that the integration time constant is independent of the impedance of the input connections, (3) equal excitatory and inhibitory capabilities, (4) complementary, bipolar outputs. and (5) controllable `refractoriness for obtaining a desired input-output characteristic. These characteristics will be more clearly understood from a discussion of the circuits of neurons of the type shown in FIG. 1 which follows.

In the circuit neuron shown in FIG. 6, the input signals a to 11 are applied through resistors 22a-22H, inclusive, to the signal combining and isolating circuit l2. These resistors may be of different values of resistance for signal weighting purposes. Signal weighting plays a prominent part in many of the neural networks to be described hereinafter. The signal combining and isolating a circuit is a common base transistor ampliiier using a P-N-P transistor 26. The collecte; of the transistor 26 is reverse biased by voltage which is applied thereto from a source of operating potential B1 which is connected to the collector through a resistor 23 in the threshold circuit 16. Since the collector is reverse biased, the common base amplifier has a relatively high output impedance, for example 500 kilohms. The input impedance of the common base amplier is relatively low and may, for example, be less than l0() ohms. A diode 30 is connected between the base and the emitter of the transistor 26 to prevent the input impedance from becoming high should the net input current go negative and to protect the transistor against high magnitude reverse currents which might cause emitter to base breakdown. The current gain of the transistor amplifier in the circuit 12 is approximately unity. Accord-- ingly, `a signal corresponding to the sum of the input signal currents ows out of collector of the transistor 26. Since the input impedance of the common base amplier including the transistor 26 is very low as compared to the resistance of the weighting resistors, a large number of inputs may be connected to the circuit 12 without significantly affecting the accuracy of the summation. Since the signals are summed across the low input impedance of the circuit 12, the sum of the inputs will be the same regardless of the number of inputs and will depend only upon the magnitude of the signals applied at the inputs.

The integration circuit 14 includes the resistor 28 and a capacitor 32. The time constant of this circuit is independent of the resistance of the input connections, since the common base amplifier of the circuit 12 has a high output impedance.

The threshold circuit 16 includes an unijunction transistor 34 which has its input electrode connected to the integration circuit 16 output. For a description of unijunction transistors, reference may be had to General Electric Transistor Manual, fifth edition (General Electric Co., Liverpool, N.Y., 1960), Section 13, pps. 138, et seq. The threshold level i9 of the unijunction transistor is set by the source of operating voltage -B1. The characltu tcristics of a unijunction transistor are that its output impedance is high until a voltage exceeding the threshold level is applied to its control electrode. Then, the output impedance measured between the output electrode of the transistor 34 drops, for example from l5 kilohms to 5 kilobms. Accordingly, a negative going pulse appears at the output 38 of the unijunction transistor 34 when the signal at the control electrode of the transistor 34 exceeds the threshold level.

The pulse generating circuit 18 includes complementary transistors 46 and 42 which, respectively, are of N-P-N and P-N-P types. The collector to emitter junctions of the transistors 41)' and 42 are in series between sources of operating voltage -l-BZ and 132. The transistors 40 and 42 are, respectively, biased to saturation in their quiescent state by the source of operating voltage -l-B1. Quiescently` the outputs x and y are at approximately zero volts, since both transistors 40 and 42 are saturated and their collectors are connected to sources of operating voltage -l-B2 and B2 of opposite and approximately equal value which are substantially balanced with respect to each other.

When a negative triggering pulse appears at the output 38 of the threshold circuit 16, the N-P-N transistor 40 is cut off and, in turn, cuts oti the transistor 42. The x output goes positive and is clamped to a positive voltage equal to the voltage of the source Bl by a clamping diode 44 connected by the .r output and the source of operating voltage -l-Bl. The y output similarly goes negative and is clamped to the voltage equal to the source Bl voltage by a clamping diode 46, which is connected between the y output and the source El. Accordingly, the output voltage in the .r and the y outputs of the pulse generators will be bi-polnr and complementary. The negative output from the collector of the transistor 42 is coupled to the base of the other transistor 40 through a capacitor 48. This capacitor 48 prevents the base of the transistor 40 from becoming positive under the iniiuence of the voltage from the source of operating potential +B1 for a given period of time determined by the time constant of the circuit associated with capacitor 48. At the end of this given period of time, the transistors 40 and 42 return to their saturated quiescent states.

A diode 50 decouples the threshold circuit 16 from the pulse generating circuit 18 for the duration of the output pulse from the pulse generating circuit, since it is reverse biased by the negative voltage transmitted through the coupling capacitor 48 while the output pulse persists. This diode 5t) is normally forward biased from the source of operating potential -l-Bl through a resistor 52. Another diode 54 is connected to the base of the transistor 42. This diode is forward biased from the source of operating voltage B1 through a resistor 56. This forward biased diode 54 compensates for the voltage drop from collector to base of the transistor 42 during quiescent operation and makes the y output of the pulse generating circuit 18 almost zero volts rather than a few tenths of a volt positive.

The pulse generating circuit 18 is a monostable multivibrator or one-shot circuit since it generates a single pulse for each triggering pulse. The pulse generating circuit is also generally useful as a pulse amplifier. The coupling capacitor 48 may be eliminated and pulses may be applied to the base of the transistor 40. The circuit will then provide bipolar output pulses in response to negative input pulses. A pulse amplifier circuit, such as shown in FIG. 6, may be used in digital circuits in those cases Where signals representing a bit and its complement are desired.

The refractory circuit 20 prevents the neuron from firing for the duration of the output pulse. This refractory circuit includes a diode 58 and a resistor 60 connected between the negative, y output of the pulse generating circuit 18 and the control electrode of the unijunction transistor 34. When the neuron tires, the negative output pulse will be transmitted by the diode 58 and hold the control electrode at a negative level for the duration of the output pulse. The refractory circuit 20 prevents the integrating circuit 14 from charging to a level which would cause the threshold circuit 16 `to fire. Accordingly, the tiring rate of the threshold circuit 16 cannot be greater than the firing rate of the pulse generating circuit 18. The refractory circuit thereby insures that the output pulse rate and the threshold circuit 16 firing rate correspond.

When the unijunction transistor 34 fires, the impedance between the control electrode and the lower one of the output electrodes (the one connected to the capacitor 32) drops to a very low value. Accordingly, the capacitor 32 discharges when the threshold circuit 16 lires. The period of time for the integration circuit 14 to charge to the threshold potential after discharging is a function of the amplitude of the input signals or the input pulse rate. Thus, the output pulse rate of the neuron is a measure of how much the input signal amplitude or input pulse rate exceeds the threshold. This is a no-n-linear function, `as shown in FIGS. 3 to 5. because of the nonlinear rate of charging of the integration circuit 14.

FIG. 8 illustrates the relationship between the time of charging of the integration circuit 14 and the amplitude of the input signal applied thereto. Curve a represents a short charging time t1 when a large amplitude input signal is applied to the integration circuit. Curves b and c represent input signals of successively lower magnitude. When the threshold is reached, the integrating circuit discharges rapidly as shown by the steep descending portions aa, bb, cc, respectively, of each of the curves a, b, and c. A neuron having a threshold circuit which is discharged upon charging to the threshold level is especially suitable for use in receptor neurons which respond to analog signals. Such signals may be derived in response to any event to be analyzed such as a tone, a speech pattern, light pattern, or the like. Since the integration circuit discharges rapidly when the analog input signal reaches threshold level, the integration circuit can charge again to the new level of the input signal and thereby accurately follow variations in the level of the analog signal.

`Other neurons, termed logic or pulse neurons, are especially `suitable for logically processing information which may be in the form of pulse trains from other neurons, such as other receptor neurons. In such logic neurons it is desirable to provide continuous tiring so long as the input signal pulse nate or amplitude is above the threshold. A circuit for a logic neutron will be described hereinafter in connection with FIG. 9 of the drawing.

Another neuron circuit is shown in FIG. 7. This circuit may have a plurality of inputs a to n which are connected thereto through weighting resistors 22a to 22n. Where circuits and components of FIG. 7 are similar to the circuit and component in FIG. 6, like reference numerals are used in FIG. 7. A signal combining an isolation circuit 12 similar to the one shown in FIG. 6 responds to the inputs ato n. This circuit 12 is connected to integration circuit 14 including a resistor 28 and a capacitor 32. The threshold circuit 16 includes an N-P-N transistor 62. This transistor is normally biased to cut-olf by a source of operating voltage -B1. The threshold level of the transistor 62 is set by a voltage divider including three resistors 64, 66 and 68 which are connected in series between the sources of operating voltage |B1 and Bb The emitter voltage established by this voltage divider determines the threshold of the circuit 16. The output 38 of the threshold circuit 16 is a negative pulse generated when the transistor 62 is turned on in response to a positive base voltage greater than the threshold level. This negative pulse triggers the pulse generating circuit 18. The y output is connected to the refractory circuit 20, including a resistor 70 which connects the y output to the base of a P-N-P transistor 72. The emitter to collector path of this transistor 72 is connected through a resistor 74 across the capacitor 32 in the integrating circuit 14. The transistor 72 is normally non-conductive, since the base is quiescently at zero volts. Upon firing of the neuro-n, a negative pulse is applied to the base of the transistor 72. The transistor 72 conducts `heavily thereby discharging the capacitor 32. Accordingly, the refractory circuit prevents the integrating circuit from charging to threshold potential for the duration of an output pulse from the neuron. The impedance presented by the transistor 72 may be varied by varying the value of the resistor 74. Accordingly, the integrating circuit may be discharged by varying amounts, depending upon the value of that resistor 74. The characteristics of the neuron shown in FIG. 7 are similar to the characteristics of the neuron shown in FIG. 6. However, the circuit of FIG. 7 is somewhat less expensive, since it permits the use of two presently relatively inexpensive transistors of the usual type instead of a presently relatively expensive unijunction transistor.

Referring to FIG. 9 there is shown another circuit neuron. Parts of the neuron of FIG. 9 which are similiar to parts of the neuron of FIG. 6 are designated by like reference numerals. The neuron of FIG. 9 may have a number of inputs a to n which are connected to a signal combining and isolating circuit 12 through weighting resistors 22a to 22n. The combined signals are applied to an integrating circuit 14 tand thence to a threshold circuit 16. The threshold circuit 16 of FIG. 9 is similar to the threshold circuit of FIG. 7 in that it includes an N-P-N transistor 62 and a threshold setting voltage divider including resistors 64, 66, and 68. This circuit establishes a quiescent threshold @q at the emitter. The output 38 of the threshold circuit 16 triggers a pulse generating circuit 18. The positive output (x) of the pulse generating circuit is fed back through the refractory circuit 20 to the threshold circuit 16. This refractory circuit includes a capacitor 76 which is connected across one of the voltage divider resistors 64 and a resistor 78 which is connected between the collector of the transistor 62 and the resistor 78.

When the neuron lires, the transistor 62 conducts heavily and the current through the emitter resistor 68 of the voltage divider increases. The voltage Ve at the emitter of the transistor 62 increases (see FIG. l0). After a short interval (illustrated by the step in FIG. l0), the pulse generating circuit generates a pulse which is fed back through the resistors 78 and 64 and the collector to emitter path of the transistor to the emitter resistor 64. The voltage at the emitter thereby again increases. The fed back output pulse and the increased voltage across the resistor 68 due to conduction through the transistor 62 add together and raise the threshold level of the threshold circuit 16 for the duration of the positive output pulse. The duration of the pulse is labeled in FIG. l() as tpulses. A positive voltage appears at the terminal of the capacitor 76 which is connected to the collector of the transistor 62. The capacitor charges to this positive voltage. After the end of the output pulse, the capacitor discharges. The trailing edge of the curve in FIG. l() results from the discharge of the capacitor. The voltage across the capacitor also appears at the emitter of the transistor 62 and causes the threshold to be raised above the threshold 9p for a period of time after the pulse subsides. This period of time can be adjusted by ladjusting the value of the capacitor 76 and/or of the resistors connected thereto.

Since the integrating circuit 14 is not discharged, the transistor 62 in the threshold circuit 16 will continue to fire, if the signal level in the output of the integrating circuit remains above the threshold Hq. However, since the threshold level is raised after each firing and returns to its original value Hq slowly over a period of time, the intervals between successive irings will depend upon how much the input signal exceeds the threshold Hq. For example, if the input signal amplitude is slightly greater than the threshold amplitude @q the output will be a single pulse since the threshold circuit will not fire again until the capacitor discharges almost entirely. When the input signal amplitude is increased, a second pulse will follow the first pulse before `the threshold returns to q (before the capacitor 76 discharges). If the input signal amplitude is still higher, the threshold will still be exceeded immediately after the termination of the first output pulse. Accordingly, the output pulses will be still closer together. The pulse rate is, therefore, a function of the extent by which the input signal amplitude exceeds the threshold Bq.

Pulses will be generated so long as the input signal exceeds the threshold q. The rate at which these pulses are generated depends upon how much the threshold is exceeded. The pulses will stop as soon as the input signal amplitude drops below the threshold. The non-linear input-output characteristics illustrated in FIGS. 3 to 5 `are therefore obtained with the logic neuron shown in FIG. 9.

Neural Logic Networks Referring to FIG. ll there is shown a network for performing the logical function of determining inequality between two input signals. In the drawing, one input signal may be applied to the input a of positive pulses and the other input may be applied to the signal input b. Both inputs a and b may be positive signals. An inverter circuit 81 is connected to input b so as to invert the polarity of the signals applied to that input. This inverter may be an amplifier circuit of a type known in the art. When the input b signal is obtained from the y output of another neuron, the inverter 81 may be dispersed with. The network of FIG. ll includes a neuron circuit 80 which may be of the type described above. This neuron circuit 80 includes a signal combining and isolating circuit having a common base transistor amplifier 26. The signal inputs a and b are applied, respectively, through weighting resistors 82 and 84 to the neuron circuit 80 by connection to the emitter of the transistor 24. Another input to the neuron circuit Si) is an adjustable input voltage designated in the drawing as VT. The effective threshold Q9 is the built-in threshold less VT. This input VT is obtained from a source of positive voltage -I-B and through a variable resistor 86.

The outputs x and y of the network of FIG. ll provide an answer to the question: Is signal input a, minus the effective threshold amplitude Qa, greater than inhibitory signal input b? A pulse output will be obtained at the outputs x and y, if the answer to this question is yes. When the neuron circuit 80 fires, the firing rate of the output pulses at the outputs x or y is a measure of how much (r1-Q0) exceeds b.

The voltage input VT is selected empirically to insure that the negative inhibitory input signals are transmitted by a common base transistor amplifier 24 to the integration circuit of the neuro-n 80 with an inhibition effect equal to the excitation effect of excitatory signals of corresponding magnitude. The voltage input VT is a positive voltage which biases the emitter of the transistor 26 in the forward direction to a point approximately mid-way along the load line of the amplifier circuit 24 in the active region of its operating characteristics. Accordingly, the transistor 26 will have a large dynamic range of operation which is approximately equal for excitatory and inhibitory signals. The threshold Q9 is a function of the voltage VT and of the threshold level 6 set by the threshold circuit 16 (FIG. 1). By proper selection of the value of VT the effective threshold Q=(0- VT) can be adjusted by changing VT so that small differences between the excitatory input a and the inhibitory input b can cause the neuron 80 to fire.

FIG. 12 shows the characteristics of the inequality determining network of FIG. l1 having different magnitudes of input voltage VT, namely VTT, VT2, and VT3 which are respectively, of successively lower voltage.

Three curves VTT, VTZ, VT3 define the ranges of excitatory input signal a and the inhibitory input signal b in which the neuron fires. The neuron 80 fires, when the intersection of a horizontal line and a vertical line drawn, respectively, from the ordinate and abscissa of the characteristic lies above the one of line VTT, VT2, or VT3 corresponding to the magnitude of the input voltage VT which is applied to the neuron 80. The altitude of the point of intersection over the corresponding line VTT, VT2, or VT3 is a measure of the `firing rate of the neuron 80. The effective thresholds Q01, Q02, and Q93 corresponding, respectively, to VT1, VfL-2, and VT3 are shown on the ordinate of the characteristic of FIG. 12. FIG. l2 shows that the minimum difference between input a and input b which will cause the neuron to rc decreases with increasing input voltage VT. Thus, a relatively smaller magnitude input a fires the neuron 80 when VT equals VTT and a relatively larger magnitude input a fires the neuron 8l) when VT equals VT3.

The relative effect on the neuron 80 of different input signals, either excitatory or inhibitory, may be selected by the use of appropriate weighting resistors, such as the resistors 82 and 84. The considerations which mediate the choice of the resistor values of the weighting resistors S2 and 84 are generally applicable to neural networks and systems to be described hereinafter. These considerations are discussed in connection with the inequality determination neural network of FIG. 11 solely in the interest of illustration of the principles involved.

The range of values of the weighting resistors is established by circuit considerations involved in coupling of successive neurons to each other. The weighting resistors should be of low enough resistance not to attenuate the input signals so that the input signal magnitudes are in the range of thermal drift currents in the transistors comprising the neuron circuits. This prevents sporadic firing of the neuron depending upon the ambient temperatures. The weighting resistors, however, must not be of such small resistance values as to cause overload of the output of a neuron circuit. When one neuron must drive a plurality of other neurons, called fanout, the weighting resistances should be high enough to prevent overloading the output of the driving neuron despite the effective connection of several weighting resistors in parallel. It has been found that weighting resistors of between 10 kilohms and 500 kilohms are suitable and satisfy the logic and coupling requirements of the neural networks.

The choice of specific values for the weighting resistors within the suitable operating range of resistance values may be empirical. A minimum output firing rate from a neuron which will be considered significant is selected. This selection takes into consideration sporadic firing due to the non-coincidence of excitatory and inhibitory inputs and cross-talk effects from other neurons. This pulse rate may, for example, be 50 pulses per second. A pulse generator providing input pulses of proper polarity at an expected pulse rate is coupled to the input of the neuron through calibrated variable resistors. The variable resistors are varied so that, with desired input pulse rates, the minimum significant output pulse rate is generated. In the case of the inequality determining network of FIG. ll, the Weighting resistors 82 and 84 are desirably 0f equal resistance` Variable resistors may be used to derive the exact resistance value for the resistors 82 and 84 by trial.

Referring to FIG. 13 there is shown a neural network for emphasizing or magnifying small, mutual differences between the amplitudes of two inputs. Outputs a' and b' corresponding to inputs a and b, but having `the differences therebetween much greater than the differences between a and b, are provided by the network of FIG. 13. The network of FIG. 13 forms the logical function of mutual inhibition, that is, each neuron output y inhibits the other such that the small differences between the input signals 11 are magnified. The neural network of FIG. 13 is useful for enhancing the contrast between two events, such as two tones, two patterns or the like. This contrast enhancement may be used for feature abstraction where the significant feature to be examined is the difference or separation between two quantities.

The mutual inhibition network of FIG. 13 includes two neurons 88 and 90. Inputs a and b, which are excitatory inputs, are separately applied to the neurons 88 and 90 through Weighting resistors 92 and 94. The negative output y of the neuron 88 is connected, as an inhibitory input, to the neuron 90 through a weighting resistor 96. Similarly, the y output of the second neuron 90 is connected through a weighting resistor 98 to another input of the neuron 88. Thus, each neuron has a different excitatory signal input and an inhibitory input corresponding to the inhibitory output of the other neuron. The weighting resistors 96 and 98 in the inhibitory inputs are larger in value than the weighting resistors 92 and 94 in the excitatory inputs so as to prevent one neuron from completely inhibiting the other.

The operation of the mutual inhibition network is characterized in FIG. 14. The differences between input signal tiring rate (a-b) is reected as a greater difference in the output ring rate (a-b).

For example, for input signal a greater in magnitude than input signal b, the magnitude of the inhibitory input to the neuron 88 is represented as -kb', where k is a constant less than unity, due to attenuation of the y (negative) output of the neuron 88 by the weighting resistor 98. Similarly, the magnitude of the inhibitory input to the other neuron 90 is represented by -ka. The constant k has the same value because the weighting resistors 96 and 98 are of equal resistance, The output of the neuron 8S is, therefor, proportional to (a-rb) and the output of the other neuron 90 is proportional to (EJ-Juf). The difference of the outputs a' and b is (fz-b)+k(a-b). Thus (ab) is greater than (cz-b) by k(a-b').

A mutual inhibition network may be provided for more than two inputs by providing additional neurons for more than two inputs by providing additional neurons for each input and by connecting the inhibitory outputs of certain ones of the neurons to the inputs of certain others thereof. For example, by connecting the inhibitory outputs of the neurons 88 and 90 to inputs of a third neuron together with a third excitatory input c, the dif ference between c and the sum of a and b may be contrasted or enhanced.

In FIG. 14 there is shown a neural logic network which is analogous to digital networks which perform the AND function. Since input signals to neural networks have a range of values, merely combining inputs in a single neuron does not :satisfy the logical AND function because an output from that single neuron might occur when only one large amplitude input signal is present. For the AND function, an output is desired so long as two inputs are present even through the amplitudes may be very small. Three of these neural networks 100, 102, and 104 are shown in FIG. l` An excitatory input a is applied through a weighting resistor 106 to the neuron 100. An other excitatory input b is applied through a weighting resistor 108 to the second of these neurons 102. The inputs a and b are separately applied through weighting resistors 110 and 112 to the third neuron 104. The input a is applied as an inhibitory input to th-e second neuron 102. A circuit which includes an inverter 114 and a weighting resistor 120 in series with the inverter, changes the polarity of the excitatory input and converts it into an inhibitory input. The inverter 114 may be an amplifier which provides output pulses opposite in polarity to the pulses applied to the input thereof. lf an inhibitory output corresponding to the input a is available, for example, from the y output of the neuron which supplies the a input, this inhibitory signal may be applied directly through the weighting resistor 120 to the input of the neuron 102.

The b input is applied as an inhibitory input to the first neuron 100. Another inverter 118, ,similar to the inverter 114 in series with a weighting resistor 116, may be used. If, another neuron output supplies the b input, its y output may be used and the inverter 113 dispensed with. The inhibitory outputs y of the neurons and 102 are applied through separate weighting resistors 122 and 124 to other inputs of the third neuron 104. Accordingly, there are two excitatory inputs to the neuron 104 and two inhibitory inputs thereto. The weighting resistors 122 and 124 are of lower resistance value than the weighting resistors and 112 in the excitatory inputs to the neuron 104. The weighting resistors 116 and 120 in the inhibitory inputs to the neuronsl 100 and 102 are also of lower values of resistance than the weighting resistors 106 and 108 in the excitatory inputs of these neurons. The resistance values of there resistors are set forth in the following tabulation. It will be appreciated that these values are solely for purposes of iilustration.

Resistor 106--100 kilohms; Resistor 10S-100 kilohms; Resistor 110-10() kilohms', Resistor 112-100 kilohms; Resistor 116-50 kilohms; Resistor 120-50 kilohms; Resistor 122-90 kilohrns; and Resistor 124-90 kilohms.

In operation, so long as inputs a and b are present and greater than the threshold 0, the neurons 100, 102, and 104, tire and provide outputs x and y. Assuming that inputs a and b are present, both neurons 100 and 102 are heavily inhibited, since the excitatory signals are attenuated more than the inhibitory signals because the resistors 106 and 108 are of greater value than the resistors 116 and 120. The sum of the inputs to the neuron 104 is heavily excitatory because of the inhibition of the neurons 100 and 102. Thus, the neuron 104 tires indicating that the AND function is satisfied.

lf one of the inputs, for example input a, is of much greater magnitude than the other input b, only the neuron 100 may tire. The inhibitory input to the neuron 104 from the neuron 100 through the weighting resistor 122 is, however, attenuated below the sum of the excitatory inputs to the neuron 104 through the resistors 110 and 112. Accordingly, the excitatory inputs to the neuron 104 are greater than the inhibitory input thereto and the neuron 104 tires thereby satisfying the AND function.

The neuron 104 does not re, if one and only one of the inputs a and b is present, regardless of the strength of that input. For example, if input a alone is present, only the neuron 100 lires. However, the inhibitory input to the neuron 104 is relatively less attenuated by the weighting resistor 122, and the excitatory input to the neuron 104 is relatively more attenuated by the resistor 110. Accordingly, the neuron 104 will be inhibited fro-m firing.

The pulse rate of the output of the neuron 104 will also be a function of the amount by which the sum of the inputs a and b exceeds the threshold for tiring 0. The digital AND function as well as an analog AND function are therefore both provided by the network of FIG. l5.

The symbol for the network of the summation network of FIG. l5 is shown in FIG. 16. This symbol is a block similar to the general neuron symbol having inputs a and b and inhibitory outputs x and y. The block is inscribed with the Greek letter E.

Certain biological neurons are known to respond only to changes in excitation. Still other biological neurons have a response which accommodates for changes in excitation. A response to the initiation of excitation is referred to as the On response and the response to the cessation of stimulation is referred to as the Off response. The On response is usually a pulse train comprising an initial burst of pulses that occurs at the onset of an input signal, followed by a diminishing pulse rate which eventually ceases altogether. The Off response is also a pulse train. The repetition rate of the pulses in the latter train is a measure of how long ago the cessation of the input signal occurred.

A neural network which provides the On response is shown in FIG. 17. Neural networks which provide the Off response and a response which accommodates to changes in input signals are shown, respectively, in FIGS. and 23.

Referring first to FIG. 17, there is shown an electrical circuit neuron 130 which may be of the type described in connection with FIG. 1 of the drawing. An excitatory input signal a is connected to the input of the neuron 130 through a charging circuit including a resistor' 132 and a capacitor 134. The operation of the network will be more apparent from FIG. 18. It is assumed that a train of excitatory impulses (positive pulses) 136 from a preceding neuron is applied to the input a. An analog signal rather than a train of impulses may be applied to the input. The capacitor 134 charges in response to the input signal at a rate determined by the time constant of the charging circuit. A suitable time constant may be provided it the capacitor 134 has a value of capacitance of 20,000 paf. and the resistor 132 has a resistance of 100 kilohms. The time constant of the charging circuit is such that the capacitor charges quickly to a maximum value in accordance with the amplitude of the input pulses 136. The capacitor remains charged for the duration of the pulse train and then discharges into the input of the neuron. Thus the current rises rapidly and falls exponentially as shown in waveform 138. At the end of the train of pulses, another burst of current in the reverse direction occurs due to the transient when the capacitor discharges. The x (positive) output of the neuron 130 in response to the input current 138 is shown in the waveform 140. As soon as the threshold is exceeded. the neuron delivers a burst of pulses. The firing rate of the neuron increases as the input current increases and decreases as the input current decreases. The negative current at the end of the pulse train 136 has an inhibitory effect and does not cause the generation ot any more pulses. Accordingly, the On response of the neural net work is an initial burst of pulses that occurs at the onset of the input signal followed by a diminishing pulse rate. The On response of the network of FIG. 17 is closely similar to the On response of biological neural networks. The symbol for a neural network which produces an On response is shown in FIG. 19 as a block which is inscribed with the symbol NON.

Referring to FIG. 20, there is shown the neural nctwork for producing the Off response. This network includes a neuron 142 of the type shown in FIG. 1. An excitatory input signal to the neuron is applied by way of an inverter 144, which inverts the signal into an inhibitory signal, a resistor 146 and a capacitor 148. The resistor and capacitor 146 and 14.8 constitutes a charging circuit. Suitable values of resistance and capacitance may be 20,000 auf. for the capacitor 148 and 100 kilohms for the resistor 146. If an inhibitory input is available from the output of a preceding neuron circuit, the inverter 144 may be eliminated and the inhibitory input connected directly to the charging circuit.

Assuming that a train of negative pulses 150. as shown in FIG. 2l, is applied to the charging circuit, the capacitor 148 charges rapidly to a maximum negative amplitude. The current into the input of the neuron 142, as shown by waveform 152, diminishes and ceases altogether at the end of the pulse train. A transient positive current due to the discharge of the capacitor 148 occurs after the end of the pulse train. The neuron responds only to this positive transient current and generates a train of output pulses. The pulses which are generated at the x output are shown in waveform 154. The tiring rate of the neuron increases to a maximum determined Cil by the maximum amplitude of the positive current at the input of the neuron 142, and then diminishes. The peak amplitude of the input current is determined by the time constant of the charging circuit at the input of the neuron 142. A relatively long pulse train will cause the capacitor to charge to a higher voltage than a relatively short pulse train. The output pulse rate is a function of the voltage to which the capacitor 148 charges. Thus, the duration or rate of the input pulse train is related to the output pulse rate. If the duration of the input pulse train is much greater than the time constant of the charging circuit, the output pulse rate is a measure of the duration of the input pulse train. If the duration of the input pulse train is the same order as the time constant of the charging network, the output pulse rate is related to both the duration of the input pulse train and the repetition rate of the pulses therein.

The symbol for the Ott response network is shown in FIG. 22 as a block inscribed with the symbol NOFF.

Accommodation in a neural network to a change in a stimulus is a phenomenon exhibited as a change in the pulse rate at the output of the neural network. The pulse rate decreases with time although the input stimulation iS maintained constant. Accommodation also affects the threshold at which the neural network fires. For example, when excitatory stimulation increases in magnitude and remains at such increased magnitude [or a long period of time, the threshold of the neuron increases so that the neuron responds only to such later stimulation as is greater in intensity than the ambient or existing stimulation of the neuron. However, the response of the neuron `stili indicates that the earlier, continuing stimulation is present. In other words. the neuron performs the logical function of recognizing the presence of ambient excitation and changes therein.

The accommodation neural network of FIG. 23 includes a neuron 156 of the type disclosed in connection with FIG. l. An excitatory input to this neuron passes through a parallel R-C charging circuit including a capacitor 158 and a resistor 164i. Suitable values of resistance and capacitance are 500 kilohms for the resistor 16%) and 20,000 aufs. for the capacitor 158.

The input signal which is applicd to the input a of the network may be in train of pulses. such as illustrated by the waveform 162 of FIG. 24. This waveform includes pulses which are of a, relatively fast repetition rate followed by pulses which are of a relatively slow repetition rate. It will be appreciated that analog signals which vary between relatively high and relatively low levels of amplitude may also be applied to the input a.

The relativelyv short time constant of the charging circuit allows a short burst of current as the capacitor 158 charges. This current diminishes to a steady state current of amplitude determined by the amplitude of the pulses in the rst part of the pulse train 162. When the second part of the pulse train occurs and pulses begin arriving `at a much slower rate, the capacitor discharges to a negative voltage or a voltage negative with respect to the threshold, and then recharges to a voltage determined by the magnitude of the slower pulses and their repetition rate (Le. the D.C. value of the slower pulses). The .r output of the neuron is shown in waveform 166 of FIG. 24. When pulses of faster repetition rate occur, the neuron 156 responds by firing rapidly at the onset of the pulse in response to the positive portion of the current. Thereafter, while the faster pulses persist, the neuron fires at a somewhat slower but steady rate. With the onset of slower repetition rate pulses, the neuron 156 is first inhibited from tiring, and then resumes tiring at a much slower rate `than was initially thel case. Thus, a gap in the output of the network or a burst of firing from the `network indicates a change in the input signal thereto. The network, however, responds by a steady ring rate to indicate that the input signal is present. This steady rate also indicates the magnitude of the input signal. In

15 other words, the neural network of FIG. 23 functions logically by providing outputs indicative of the presence of information, and also changes in such present information.

Another logical function which is possible with biological neurons is priority response. These biological neu rons function logically to determine that two inputs have occurred and that a specilied one of these preceded the other. A neural network which performs the priority function is shown in FIG. 25. Two inputs a and b, may be applied to the `priority neural network. This network produces excitatory .r outputs and inhibitory v outputs in response to the occurrence of two inputs, a and b, within a certain period of time, if `and only if. a precedes b. The period is determined tby the time constant of thc integrating circuit of the neuron (FIG. 1). The priority network includes two neurons 170 and 172 each of the type discussed in connection with FIG. l. The excitatory input-s a and b are connected to the first of these neurons 170, separately, through Weighting resistors 174 and 176. The excitatory input b is also connected to the neuron 172 through another weighting resistor 173. The weighting resistors 174, 176 are desirably of equal resistance. The resistor 178 is of somewhat lower resistance than the re sistor 174 or 176. The inhibitory y output of the neuron 172 is fed back through a weighting resistor 188 to the input of the first neuron 170. The weighting resistor 180 is of less weight (lower resistance value) than resistors 174 or 176. The inhibitory y output of the ncuso that either input a or b, alone is insufficient to fire it.

In operation, if both inputs a and b occur simultaneously, .the first neuron 170 will be inhibited, since the inhibition input to the neuron 170 is of greater magnitude than both excitatory inputs a and b because of the rela tively low resistance Weighting resistor 180. If input b occurs within the given time period, `but before input a, the second neuron 172 inhibits the first neuron 170 so that the input a does not excite the neuron 17@ to provide an output. It is only when the input a occurs before the input b that the neuron 170 is not inhibited and the output is provided. Accordingly, the neural network of FIG. 25 functions logically to determine priority of two inputs. By using additional neurons having additional inhibitory feed back connections to the first neuron. the priority of one among several inputs may be determined.

A symbol for the priority neural network is shown in FIG. 26 as a block inscribed with the letters NP and the symbol azb to indicate that the neuron responds to the priority of a 'with respect to b within `a given time period.

Neural Systems The neural networks described in connection with FIGS. 11 through 26 may be interconnected in systems which respond to complex patterns of events. These events may be sound patterns, such as the amplitudefrequency spectrum which are representative of various phonemes. Other events may be light patterns such as are produced when light is transmitted through or reected from symlbols, letters of the alphabet and the like. Neural systems may be used `to `abstract significant features of complex patterns or to recognize certain patterns.

Systems of neural networks may also be generaliy uscful for information processing. `Complex `analog functions may be translated into simplified form b-y ncural systems which find the maxima, minima, slopes and other relationship of these complex functions. Other systems of neural networks are useful in performing arithnietical operations ori information, for example neural'systems for multiplication, addition, subtraction and the like.

FIGS 27a and 27b show a system of neural networks which is suitable for analyzing analog information, und particularly for pattern recognition of a pattern rep-resenting a speech sound, such as a phoneme. The upper portion of FIG. 27a shows two curves 186 and 188 which, respectively, represent the instantaneous frequency spectitl lf3 trum of a sound at successive times, t1 and t2. Different electrical currents correspond to the intensities of the sound at different frequencies a, b, c, d, and e and may be applied `as inputs to the system by means of signal translating devices, eg. microphones and amplifiers, such as are known in the art. These device-s may include microphone amplifiers and band pass filters. Since such electrical translations are known in the art, they are not shown in detail in the drawings.

The signal currents are applied ias input signals, a, b, c, d, `and e ithrough weighting resistors 202 to receptor neuron circuits 190, 192, 194, 196 and 198, respectively, which are interconnected as mutual inhibition neural networks similar to the network shown in FIG. 13. The receptor neurons 190, 192, 194, 196, and 198 comprise a primary level of neurons 199. FIGS. 27a and 27b are partially fragmentary. Additional inputs and neuron stages preceding input a and neuron 190 and succeeding input e and neuron 198 may be desirable. The inhibitory output y of each receptor neuron 190, `192, 194, 196 and 198 is fed hack as an inhibitor input to its two adjacent neurons through separate weighting resistors 200. The first and last of the receptor neurons (not shown) receive inhibitory outputs of their adjacent receptor neurons on the right and left, respectively. The relative weights or resistanccs of each of the weighting resistors 200 and 262 may be the same as disclosed in connection with FIG. 13.

The excitatory outputs and the inhibitory outputs y are, respectively, `applied through weighting resistors 204 and 208 to the inputs of neurons in a second level 206 of neurons which determine the differences between adjacent ones of the input signals a, b, c, d and e. Since the neurons in the primary level 199 of neurons are mutually inhibited, small differences in the inputs a to e are enhanced. Thus, the second level 206 of neurons readily abstract information as to which of the adjacent pairs of inputs is greater than the other. The second level 206 utilizes neural networks 210, 212, 214, 216, 218, 220, 222, 224, 226 and 228 of the type described in connection with FlG. 1l. The variable input VT in each of these networks 210 to 228 is not shown. However, the magnitude of VT may be equal in each of the networks and chosen as discussed in connection with FIG. 1l. Since inhibitory inputs are applied through weighting resistors 208 to the networks 210 to 228, an inverter, such as shown in FIG. 11, is not necessary. The networks 210 to 228 provide outputs when the excitatory input exceeds the inhibitory input. Thus, the neuron 210 fires when input a is greater than input it. Input ip is the input preceding the input a in the frequency rspectrum to which the system of FIG. 27 responds. This input tb to the `network 210 may be derived from another receptor neuron (not shown). The operation of the network 210 is symbolized by the inscription a tb in the block representing the network 210. The. other neural networks 212 to 228 fire when their excitatory inputs exceed their inhibitory inputs. The input to the neural network 228 is derived from a receptor neuron (not shown) which responds to the next higher frequency input b.

Summation neural networks 230, 232, 234, 236 and 238 derive `the maxima points of the pattern. These networks are of the type shown in FIG. 15. If the input a corresponds to a maxima point of the pattern, the summation network 230 will fire. Similarly, the summation networks 232, 234, 236 and 238 will fire if the input signals b, c, d and e, respectively, correspond to the maxima points of the pattern. These maxima points are significant features of the analog function to which the system responds. Accordingly, the networks 230 to 238 are feature abstriactng networks.

The inputs to the network 230 are the x (positive) outputs of the inequality determining networks 210 and 212 and are applied through weighting resistors 240 which may be of equal resistance value. Input a corresponds to a maxima point of the function, if a is greater than its preceding and succeeding inputs b and b. The summation network 230 provides an output only if inputs representing a \,b and a b are applied thereto during the period set by the integrating time constant (temporal characteristic) of the neurons constituting the network 230. Accordingly, neuron 230 lires, if, and only if, input a corresponds to a maxima point of the function. The neural networks 230, 232, 234, 236 and 238 receive their inputs through weighting resistors 242, 244, 246 and 248, respectively. Inputs are applied to the summation network 32 if, tand only if, input b is greater than its adjacent inputs a and c. The neural network 234 rcceives its inputs from the excitatory outputs of the inequality determining networks 218 and 220. Since both of these networks do not fire unless c is greater than its adjacent inputs b and d, the summation network 234 lires if c corresponds to a maxima point of the function. The summation networks 236 and 238 operate similarly to the networks 230, 232, and 234, and fire if, and only if, d or e correspond to maxima points of the function. The firing rates of the networks 230, 2.32, 234, 236 and 238 correspond to the relative height of the maxima.

Other important features of analog functions are their minima points. Such minima points may be obtained from appropriate ones of the inequality determining networks n the second level 206 of neurons. Por example, input b corresponds to a minima point, if its adjacent inputs a 'and c are both greater in magnitude than input b. Inputs c and d similarly correspond to minima points if their adjacent inputs b and d or c and e are, respectively, greater than c and d in magnitude. By Way of example, the means for abstracting information as to whether b, c, or d are minima points and the relative depth of the minima are shown in FIG. 27a. It will be appreciated that similar means may be used to derive information as to whether minima points also correspond to the other inputs a and e.

A summation network 250 lires when b corresponds to a minima. This summation network derives its inputs through weighting resistors 252 from the output of the inequality determining networks 212 and 218. The network 212 res, if input a is greater than input b and the network 218 tires, if input c is greater than input b. The summation network 250 will re if, `and only if, both inequality determining networks 212 `and 218 lire within the temporal characteristics of the network 250. Accordingly, the summation network 250 provides an output if b is less in magnitude than its adjacent inputs a and c. The rate of firing of the network 250 is a function of the relative depth of the minimum point.

summation networks 255 and 254 which, respectively, respond to inputs from` the inequality determining networks 216. 222 and 200, 226 through weighting resistors 253 `and 256 operate similarly to the summation network 250 for providing outputs if, and only if, input c or d corresponds to a minimum point of the function.

Another significant feature of an `analog function is the slope of different regions thereof. The slope of the speech pattern can either be negative (decreasing amplitude with increasing frequency) or positive (increasing amplitude with increasing frequency). The slope of the function is positive if successive adjacent inputs are of increasing amplitude and negative if these successive adjacent inputs iare of decreasing amplitude. For example, if inputs a, b, and c are of successively decreasing amplitude, the slope of the function is negative, and if these inputs are of successively larger ampltude the slope is positive. By way of example, means are shown in FIG. 27a for recognizing a negative slope of the region no-f the function included by the inputs a, b, and c and for obtaining an output indicative of a positive slope in the part of the function included by the inputs c, d, and e.

A summation network 258 responds to the slope of the region of the function embraced by the input signals a, b and e. Inputs to this summation network are obtained through the weighting resistors 252 and 253, which may be of equal value, from the inequality determining networks 212 and 216. The latter networks both tire, if input a is greater than input b and if input b is greater than input c. Both excitatory inputs to the network 258 occur only if the inputs a, b, and c are of successively smaller amplitude indicative of a negative slope in the region of the function embraced by inputs a, b, and c. The firing rate of the network 258 is a function of the relative steepness of the slope.

Another summation network 260 provides an output when the slope of the portion of the function included by the inputs c, d, and e is positive. Inputs to this summation network 260 are obtained through weighting resistors 253 and 256, which are of equal resistance, from the inequality determining networks 222 and 226. The network 222 fires, if input d is greater than input c and the network 226 lires if input e is greater than input d. Outputs from both networks 222 and 226 occur, approximately simultaneously, only if the inputs c, a', and e are of successively greater amplitude. Accordingly, the summation network 260 will fire if, and only if, a positive slope exists in the region of the curve included by the inputs c, d, and e. The rate of firing of the network 260 is a function of the relative steepness of the curve.

Another significant feature of analog signals is a shift of a local maxima, a local minima or a slope from one part of the function to another at successive time intervals. For phoneme `recognition or for other pattern recognition purposes, such a shift may be characteristic of a particular sound. For example, the consonant Sounds b" as in heath g as in good," may be distinguished by examining the patterns representing these sounds at successive time intervals. The sound b is characterized by a shift in local maxima to a higher frequency, whereas the sound ",Q is characterized by a shift in local maxima to a lower frequency. Otherwise the formants (frequency-amplitude) spectra of these sounds are similar.

By way of example, means are provided in the system of FIG. 27a for obtaining an output when the local maxima shifts from around the frequency corresponding to input b to around the `frequency corresponding to input d between successive time intervals t1 and t2. This circuit includes an Off response network 262, the input of which is connected through a weighting resistor 264 to the y output of the summation network 232. This network 232 res when input b is at a maximum point of the pattern. An On response network 266 is connected through a weighting resistor 268 to the excitatory x out- `put of the summation network 236. The summation network 236 provides an output in response to a local maximum at a `frequency which is about that of the d input. A summation network 270 is connected through weighting resistors 272 which are suitably of equal resistance to the x outputs of the Off response network 262 and of the On response network 266. The summation network 270 fires if, and only if, the maximum shifts from b to d, since the Off response network 262 tires when the b input ceases and the On response network 266 lires when the d input is initiated.

It is important to obtain information as to which of two local maxima or local minima occurs first. By way of example, a means for determining whether a local maximum corresponding to input b occurred before a local maximum corresponding to input d is shown in FIG. 27b. This means comprises a priority determining network 274 which is connected through weighting resistors 276 to the b maximum output and the d maximum output which are, respectively, obtained from the summation network 232 and the summation network 236 (FIG. 27a). The priority network operates as explained above in connection with FIG. 25 and res if, and only if,

inputs b and d are both at maxima points and input b occurs before input d. lt is apparent from the curves 186 and 188 that the latter is the case. Accordingly, the priority network 274 will tire and provide a train of output pulses. It is no-ted that networks 270 and 274 will both tire in the illustrative case shown and discussed herein. However, different logical significance attaches to the outputs of these networks and these outputs may serve different purposes.

The significant features of the analog function which as abstracted by the neural system of FIG. 27a and FIG. 27h are the following:

a maximum; a minimum b maximum; b minimum c maximum; c minimum d maximum; d minimum e maximum; d minimum Slope a, b, c, negative;

Slope c, d, e, positive;

Local maxima transition from b to d; and looal maxima prio-rity, b before d.

These significant features are only illustrative and many more `features may be abstracted by additional networks in combination of networks of the types discussed above.

These features are associated with certain events such as certain patterns or in the case of phoneme recognition of specific p-honemes. In order to recognize these phonemes response units are used, one for each phoneme. Two response units 280 and 282 are shown, by way of example, in FIG. 27b. Many `more units may be used in practice. These units 280 and 282 include weighting networks 284 and 286, neuron circuits 288 and 290, and indicators or other utilization apparatus 292 and 294. The response units 280 and 282 respond to different combinations of features and reject other combinations. The other response units (not shown) may respond to still other, different combinations of features. These combinations of features are selected in accordance with the probability that these features will occur or be associated with the event to be recognized. For phoneme recognition the probabilities may be derived empirically by analysis of the features which are abstracted when the same phoneme is sounded.

The response unit 280 responds to certain `features a maximum, b maximum, and d minimum. The inputs are excitatory, except for an inhibitory input corresponding to e maximum. The weighting network 284 includes weighting resistors 296, 298, 300, 302 and 304. These resistors have different values of resistance depending upon the relative value of the output representing the feature which is applied to the neuron 288 through that resistor. The choice of values of resistance `for the case where a phoneme represented by the curve 186 is to be recognized is discussed herein for purposes of example. 288 has a threshold which is just exceeded, when the input signals thereto satisfy the pattern which is to be recognized by the response unit. It is highly improbable that another combination of input signals will have the same amplitude and cause the neuron 288 to tire. If such a probability exists, an inhibitory input is used as will be discussed hereinafter. In lthis particular case, taken for purposes of example, the curve 186 has a maximum amplitude around a point corresponding to input b. Accordingly, resistor 298 has the highest value of resistance of all of the other resistors in the weighting network 284. There is a minimum correspondence to the input d. However, this minimum does not have a depth which corresponds in amplitude to the height of the maxima at b. To equalize these differences, the weighting resistor 302 is of lower value of resistance than that of the Weighting resistor 298. The other inputs 296 and 300 are inactive when a function corresponding to the curve 186 exists. However, statistical studies of the phoneme indicated that under some conditions, such as The neuron for different speakers, there will be a distribution of local maxima at a and c rather than at b. To accommodate for this probability and to recognize when the same phoneme is spoken by several speakers, additional inputs through weighting resistors 296 and 300 are provided. The values of these resistors may be equal so as to provide the same total excitatory input just exceeding the threshold of the neuron 288, as is the case when the phoneme corresponds more exactly to the function shown by curve 186. Statistical studies may reveal that other combinations of the inputs a maximum, b maximum, c maximum and d minimum not representing the disclosed phoneme might possibly tire the neuron 188. However, these combinations of inputs also include an input corresponding to a maximum point at e. The inhibitory output of the summation circuit 238 (FIG. 27a) is, therefore, connected through the weighting resistor 304 to the input of the neuron 288. However, this weighting resistor 304 has a value of resistance lower than any of the resistors 296, 298, 300 or 302. Accordingly, the e maximum input inhibits the neuron 288 from firing in response to an undesired phoneme.

The indicator 292 may be a light or it may be conversion apparatus which provides a sound corresponding to the recognizing phoneme, o-r types a word, letter or symbol for the sound.

The other response unit 282 is connected to recognize the p-honeme represented by the curve 1818. To this end, the neuron input is connected through weighting resistors 306, 308, 309, 318, 312 and 314 in the weighting network 286, to inputs corresponding to priority of b maximum prior to a' maximum, a minimum, b maximum, c maximum, d maximum, and e minimum. The values of these resistors are adjusted to provide approximately equal inputs, the sum of which just exceeds the threshold of the neuron 290. The weighting resistor 306 which provides an inhibitory input from the network 274 to the neuron 290 is disregarded in choosing the values for the other weighting resistors. The greatest amplitude input is d maxima. Accordingly, the resistor 312 has the greatest value of resistance of all of the resistors, except the resistor 306 in the inhibitory connection. The values of the resistors 314 and 308 may be approximately equal since these minima are of about the same depth. The inputs through the resistors 309 and 310 correspond, respectively, t-o b maximum, and c maximum and `are provided to accommodate for variations in speaking and/or different speakers. Altho-ugh these inputs b maximum and c maximum do not occur when the pattern is represented by the curve 188 exists, they do occur in other patterns derived from the same phoneme. lt is desirable to absolutely inhibit the neuron 290 if, for example, a function as represented by the curve 186 precedes the function represented by the curve 188. Accordingly, the priority circuit 274 supplies the inhibitory input to the response unit 282. The neuron 290 will be inhibited from tiring, if a pattern having a maxima at b precedes a pattern having a maxima at d, as is apparently the case for the pattern represented by the curves 186 and 188. The indicator 294 responds to the tiring of the neuron 290. This indicator may be the same as the indicator 292 or may be utilization apparatus such as converts the phoneme back into acoustic form.

it will be apparent that the neuron system performs both digital (yes-no) logic and analog logic simultaneously. Thus, quantitative or analog measures of digital functions is preserved. In this manner the system combines both analog and digital processes in a unique way.

Simulated Cochlea It is recognized that the human ear has capabilities for analyzing and recognizing spoken words which have not been attained by any artificial speech recognition system. The psychological and physiological studies of the human ear have shown that the ear incorporates a complex mechanical and neural system. The psychoacoustic phenomena that characterize the functions of the ear can be ascribed to the operation of the neural system of the ear. :In order to successfully analyze sounds such as the sounds of speech, an electrical system including neural networks is provided which operates to reproduce many of the known psychoacoustic phenomena that characterize the functions of the human ear. To understand the operation of this electrical system, it is desirable to examine the human ear from a physiological point of View, and particularly to etamine the cochlea, part of the inner ear, which transforms an auditory pattern into neural signals.

Mechanically, the cochlea is a spiral membrane which is `filled with fluid. The cochlea is divided into two parts by the cochlear partition. Within the cochlear partition lie the sensory organs which translate the auditory pattern into impulses that tell the brain what is going on at the ear. The sensory organs are nerve cells known as hair cells. One end of the cochlea is connected to the stapes (stirrup) of the middle ear mechanism. The stapes is connected by way of the `anvil and hammer to the ear drum. The ear drum is at the end of the ear canal which is connected to the ear ap. The ear flap is the visible portion of the ear at the exterior of the head. The cochlear partition moves in response to the sound waves which travel through the ear canal. It has been found that the part of the coehlear partition which vibrates at maximum amplitude depends upon the frequency (pitch) of the sound. The vibration is strongest near the stapes for high frequency sound and the point of strongest vibration moves toward the end of the cochlear partition farthest away from the stapes as the ifrequency of the sound decreases. A mechanical wave starts down the cochlear partition and reaches its maximum amplitude at a place corresponding to the frequency of the wave. The wave falls away rapidly beyond this point. Thus, the cochlear partition tends to separate the various frequencies of a stimulating wave. The portion of the partition which vibrates depends on the frequency of the wave and at very low frequencies, below cycles per second, the cochlear partition vibrates es a whole. As pointed out above, this vibration is translated by the nerves in the cochlear partition into electrical signals. Since signals are generated at different places in the cochlea depending upon the frequency or pitch of the sound, the frequency separating action of the cochlea has been called the place theory of hearing.

There is another theory which accounts for the translation of auditory patterns into electrical signals in the cochlea. This is called the volley theory. According to this theory, the nerves in the cochlear `partition generate sequences of electrical impulses, the repetition rate or number of impulses in the volleys depending upon the pitch of the sound. `For low frequency sounds, the repetition rate or number of impulses is higher, since a group of biological neurons can generate more pulses during each cycle of the sound than for sounds of very high pitch. The volleys of impulses are also synchronized with the stimulating sound waves since the biological neurons are excited at a rate related to the `frequency of the stimulating waves.

There are many psychoacoustic phenomena which may be accounted for in accordance with the place theory of hearing and other psychoacoustic phenomena which can be accounted for by the volley theory. Masking of high frequency sounds by low frequency sounds may be understood from the place theory. A low frequency tone will strongly vibrate the cochlear partition between the stapes and points of maximum vibration spaced beyond the stapes. The high frequency stimulation is, therefore, operative on an already strongly vibrating portion of the cochlear partition. The cochlear partition vibration due to a high frequency tone does not extend along the cochlear partition as far as the vibrations due to tones of low frequency. Accordingly, the low frequency tone is clearly perceived whereas the high frequency' is masked or hidden by the low frequency.

A phenomenon which may be accounted for by the volley theory is the perception of the fundamental frequency of a sound containing many overtones, although the fundamental tone is not present. The volleys of impulses follow the envelope of the complex sound corresponding to the overtones. This frequency of the -envelope corresponds to the frequency of the fundamental tones. Accordingly, the fundamental is perceived.

An artificial cochlea, capable of simulating electrically many of the psychoacoustic phenomena of the cochlea, is also capable of analyzing auditory patterns and providing information as to the signicant features of these patterns in a manner similar to the human ear. Based on this information, sounds of speech may be recognized.

Referring to FIG. 28, there is shown a simulated cochlea including a low pass filter structure or transmission line 320. The filter structure 320, it has been found, is characterized by an electrical response to audio frequency electrical signals of different frequency similar to the mechanical-electrical response of the cochlea to sound waves of different frequency. This filter structure 320 includes a plurality of filter sections, three of which 322, 324, and 326, are shown. The filter sections 322, 324 and 326 have successively lower cut-off frequencies. The structure 320 is terminated by a resistor 328 having a resistance equal to the characteristic impedance Rc of the line 320. The low pass structure (line) 320 is driven by audio frequency electrical signals which are translated from sound signals by a microphone 330 and amplified by an amplifier 332. The amplifier 332 desirably has automatic gain control so that the line 320 is not overloaded by excessively high signal levels. Neurons 334, 336, and 338 of a primary level 348` of neurons, each of which corresponds to a different line section, are connected to their corresponding line 320 sections. Although only three neurons are shown for purposes of illustration, it will be appreciated that a different neuron is provided for each section of the structure 320. Neurons 342, 344, and 346 of a second level 348 of neurons, also corresponding to different ones of the line sections, are connected separately between adjacent neurons in the primary level 340 of neurons.

The successive sections 322, 324, and 326 of the structure 320 are connected to excitatory input connections 350, 352 and 354 of the neurons 334, 336 and 338, respectively. These connections include rectitiers 356, 358, and 360 which pass positive currents. lt will be recalled that the neurons illustrated are excited by positive currents and inhibited by negative currents. The excitatory connections 350, 352 and 354, respectively, include weighting resistors 362, 364, and 366. Although half wave rectifiers, in the form of the diodes 356, 358, and 368, are shown, the system may, alternatively, use full wave rectiers such as bridge rectifier circuits. inhibitory connections are also made to each of the neurons 334, 336, and 338 from the input to the low pass structure 320. Thes inhibitory connections include weighting resistors 368, 370, and 372 connected respectively to inputs of the neurons 334, 336, and 338. A rectifier in the form of a diode 374 which is polarized to pass negative current from the input of the structure 320 through the resistors 368, 370, and 372 is provided in the inhibition connections. The values of the resistors mentioned above are chosen to provide characteristics for the simulated cochlea system which simulate the threshold of hearing characteristie and equal loudness level characteristic of the human ear. These characteristics are illustrated in FIG. 29 which includes a family of curves T, lr, v, w, x, and y of differently perceived loudness levels for sounds of different intensity which vary in frequency. The curve T represents the normal threshold of hearing for sounds of different frequency. The curves u, v, w, x, and y represent 

1. ELECTRICAL APPARATUS WHICH SIMULATES THE COCHLEA, SAID APPARATUS COMPRISING A PLURALITY OF ELECTRICAL CIRCUIT NEURONS, MEANS FOR SEPARATELY EXCITING SAID NEURONS TO RESPOND TO DIFFERENT FREQUENCY COMPONENTS OF AN ACOUSTIC ELECTRICAL SIGNAL INCLUDING A TRANSMISSION LINE HAVING SUCCESSIVE SECTIONS WHICH PASS SUCCESSIVELY LOWER FREQUENCIES OF SAID SIGNAL, AND MEANS FOR EXCITING AND INHIBITING DIFFERENT ONES OF SAID NEURONS WITH THE SIGNAL PASSED, RESPECTIVELY, WITH A FIRST AND A SECOND OF DIFFERENT PAIRS OF ADJACENT SECTIONS OF SAID LINE. 